The cricketing community is closely watching the ongoing comparison between Virat Kohli from India and Babar Azam from Pakistan. Following Pakistan’s recent performance against India in the T20 World Cup, former Indian wicketkeeper Dinesh Karthik has shared his insights to add clarity to this discussion.
The matchup reached a critical point during a tense chase in Colombo. Pakistan was chasing 176 runs, needing their captain to play a key role. However, Babar could only manage 5 runs off 7 balls before being dismissed by Axar Patel, a decision that raised eyebrows. Karthik highlighted that this incident wasn’t just about the score, but also about Babar’s mindset at a crucial moment.
Dinesh Karthik comments on the Kohli-Babar debate
In a discussion on Cricbuzz, Karthik expressed that Babar’s early exit reflected a lack of competitive spirit. Despite Babar’s technical skill, Karthik pointed out a key weakness in his approach during critical moments—the areas where Kohli has made his mark.
“I cannot imagine Virat Kohli playing that shot that early in the innings. That is submission,” Karthik said. He emphasized that true greatness comes from handling pressure effectively, not just performing well during easy times. Karthik believes that Babar’s dismissal showed uncertainty in his capability to lead the team successfully.
While Kohli is known for his ability to manage risks and guide the innings when the pressure is high, Babar’s struggle to take on that responsibility has drawn significant criticism. Following Pakistan’s 61-run defeat, calls for changes in team leadership have intensified, widening the gap between Babar and Kohli’s esteemed status.
T20 World Cup performance comparison: Virat Kohli vs. Babar Azam
To understand the basis of Karthik’s criticism, one can look at the statistical differences between the two players in T20 World Cups. The figures reveal a contrast between consistency and occasional brilliance.
| Statistic | Virat Kohli (2012-2024) | Babar Azam (2021-2026) |
| Matches/Innings | 35 / 33 | 21 / 20 |
| Runs | 1,292 | 615 |
| Average | 58.72 | 34.16 |
| Strike Rate | 128.81 | 111.81 |
| 50s | 15 | 5 |
| Fours / Sixes | 111 / 35 | 54 / 9 |
The statistics show a notable disparity in impact. Kohli’s average of 58.72 over years of World Cup play is nearly double Babar’s. Additionally, Kohli has hit 35 sixes, while Babar has only managed 9, despite competing in a time where power-hitting is crucial.
Karthik’s argument stands firm: true greatness is defined by success under pressure. Until Babar can demonstrate a similar capacity for delivering crucial performances like Kohli, the conversation may remain focused on Kohli’s achievements.
